Indiana · The medical review panel
The medical review panel: what it is, how it is chosen, and what its opinion does
Before most Indiana malpractice claims can reach a court, a medical review panel must give its opinion (opens in a new tab). This page follows a claim through it: the proposed complaint, who sits on the panel, what the panel reads, what it can decide, and what the opinion does afterward.
The short answer
What is a medical review panel in Indiana?
A panel of one attorney and three health care providers (opens in a new tab) that reads the evidence on a claim against a provider qualified under the Medical Malpractice Act and gives an expert opinion on whether the evidence supports the conclusion that the defendant acted or failed to act within the appropriate standards of care (opens in a new tab). The attorney chairs the panel and has no vote. A court action may not be commenced (opens in a new tab) before the opinion, with limited exceptions, and the opinion can be used at trial, though it is not conclusive (opens in a new tab).
When does a claim have to go to a panel?
When it is against a health care provider qualified under the Act. The rule is that an action against a health care provider may not be commenced in a court in Indiana (opens in a new tab) before the proposed complaint has been presented to a panel and an opinion is given by the panel (opens in a new tab). A provider who has not qualified is not covered by this article (opens in a new tab).
There are two exceptions. The claimant and every defendant can agree that the claim is not to be presented to a medical review panel (opens in a new tab), in a signed writing attached to the complaint. And a patient can go straight to court with a declaration that the patient seeks damages from the health care provider in an amount not greater than fifteen thousand dollars (opens in a new tab), which bars the patient from recovering any amount greater (opens in a new tab) unless the injury proves more serious than the patient reasonably believed.
How does a claim start?
With a proposed complaint. The Department of Insurance says filing a proposed complaint initiates a medical malpractice claim against the named health care providers (opens in a new tab), and a copy goes to the Commissioner of Insurance. It is considered filed when a copy of the proposed complaint is delivered or mailed by registered or certified mail to the commissioner (opens in a new tab), and that filing tolls the applicable statute of limitations (opens in a new tab) until ninety days after the claimant receives the panel’s opinion.
The Department’s page sets out what the filing needs. Among other things, it must carry the start and end dates of the alleged occurrence of malpractice (opens in a new tab), so the Commissioner can tell whether each defendant was qualified at the time, and it names the county of venue. The Department cannot make legal or medical determinations and cannot provide legal advice (opens in a new tab), and it asks that medical records not be sent with the complaint.
A filing does not form a panel by itself. Not earlier than twenty days after the filing of a proposed complaint, either party may request the formation of a medical review panel (opens in a new tab), and the Department notes that a panel will not be formed if neither party requests one (opens in a new tab).
Who sits on the panel, and how are they chosen?
The chair comes first. The parties have fifteen days after the request to select a panel chairman by agreement (opens in a new tab). If they cannot agree, either side can ask the clerk of the Supreme Court for a random list of five attorneys with offices in the county of venue designated in the proposed complaint or in a contiguous county (opens in a new tab), and the sides strike names in turn, the plaintiff first, until one is left.
Then the providers. Each party to the action has the right to select one health care provider, and upon selection, the two health care providers thus selected shall select the third panelist (opens in a new tab). Each step has fifteen days. With a single defendant who is an individual, two of the panelists selected must be members of the profession (opens in a new tab) of that defendant, and if the defendant specializes in a limited area, two must specialize in the same area as the defendant (opens in a new tab).
Either side can make a written challenge without cause (opens in a new tab) to a panelist within ten days of the selection. Before reviewing anything, each panelist swears in writing to consider the evidence without bias, and neither a party, a party’s agent, a party’s attorney, nor a party’s insurance carrier may communicate with any member of the panel (opens in a new tab), except as the law allows, until the opinion is given.
What does the panel read?
Evidence in writing, which the parties submit: medical charts, x-rays, lab tests, excerpts of treatises, depositions of witnesses including parties, and any other form of evidence allowable by the medical review panel (opens in a new tab). Depositions can be taken before the panel meets, and both parties shall have full access to any material submitted to the panel (opens in a new tab).
The chair may establish a reasonable schedule for submission of evidence (opens in a new tab), but must allow enough time to present the facts. Once the evidence is in, either side can, on ten days’ notice, convene the panel (opens in a new tab) and question its members before they report. That is the firm’s chance to take the panel through the chart, so the work of the claim happens here.
What can the panel decide?
It answers one question: whether or not the evidence supports the conclusion that the defendant or defendants acted or failed to act within the appropriate standards of care as charged in the complaint (opens in a new tab). Within thirty days after reviewing the evidence and any questioning, it gives one or more of these opinions, in writing and signed:
- The evidence supports the conclusion that the defendant or defendants failed to comply with the appropriate standard of care as charged in the complaint (opens in a new tab).
- The evidence does not support the conclusion that the defendant or defendants failed to meet the applicable standard of care as charged in the complaint (opens in a new tab).
- There is a material issue of fact, not requiring expert opinion, bearing on liability for consideration by the court or jury (opens in a new tab).
- The conduct complained of was or was not a factor of the resultant damages (opens in a new tab), and if it was, any disability and its extent and duration, and any permanent impairment and its percentage.
How long does it take?
The statute says the panel shall give its expert opinion within one hundred eighty days after the selection of the last member of the initial panel (opens in a new tab). The time for choosing the panel comes before that. If the panel misses the date, it shall submit a report to the commissioner, stating the reasons for the delay (opens in a new tab), so the statute itself expects that some will. If nothing happens in a case at the Department for two years, the Commissioner may file a motion to dismiss the case (opens in a new tab) in the Marion County Circuit Court.
What happens after the opinion?
The claim can go to court, whichever way the panel came out. The report is admissible as evidence in any action subsequently brought by the claimant in a court of law (opens in a new tab), but the opinion is not conclusive (opens in a new tab), and either party, at its own cost, has the right to call any member of the medical review panel as a witness (opens in a new tab). At trial the patient has the right to a trial by jury (opens in a new tab), by demand.
The clock starts again. The proposed complaint stopped it only to and including a period of ninety days following the receipt of the opinion of the medical review panel by the claimant (opens in a new tab), so the date the opinion arrives matters.
Then there is the panel’s bill. Each provider member can be paid up to five hundred dollars for all work performed as a member of the panel (opens in a new tab), and the chair is paid by the day, and the cost falls on the side in whose favor the majority opinion is written (opens in a new tab). If there is no majority opinion, each side shall pay fifty percent of the cost (opens in a new tab). The Department says the average cost of a panel is approximately $4,000 (opens in a new tab).
Frequently asked questions
Can I skip the panel?
Only if every party agrees in writing (opens in a new tab), or if the claim seeks no more than fifteen thousand dollars (opens in a new tab). A claim against a provider who is not qualified under the Act is not covered by this article (opens in a new tab).
Can I file in court while the panel is working?
Yes, with limits. A claimant may commence an action in court at the same time the proposed complaint is being considered by a medical review panel (opens in a new tab), but the complaint cannot identify the defendant, the claimant is prohibited from pursuing the action (opens in a new tab), and the court does little beyond setting a trial date until the panel has given its opinion.
Who pays for the panel?
The winner, which surprises people. The fees are paid by the side in whose favor the majority opinion is written (opens in a new tab), and split evenly if there is no majority. The Department of Insurance puts the average cost of a panel at approximately $4,000 (opens in a new tab).
If the panel rules against me, is the case over?
No. The opinion is not conclusive (opens in a new tab). A case can still be filed, though a jury can hear the opinion, and a lawyer has to weigh that before filing.
Can I or my lawyer talk to the panel members?
Not privately. Neither a party, a party’s agent, a party’s attorney, nor a party’s insurance carrier may communicate with any member of the panel (opens in a new tab), except as the law allows, before the opinion. Either side can convene the panel (opens in a new tab) and question it after the evidence is in.
Keep reading
- 01
Indiana law
The two-year clock, the panel, who the Act covers, your records, a patient’s own fault, the cap, fees and death cases.
Indiana law page - 02
The cap and the Fund
The limit for each period, what a qualified provider pays, how a claim reaches the Fund, and the limit on fees.
Explore the cap and the Fund - 03
Qualified providers
What qualifying means, how to check a provider and the dates of the care, and what changes if the provider is not covered.
Explore qualified providers - 04
A child’s claim
Only a child under six gets more time, to the eighth birthday. Who brings the claim, and how a court reviews a settlement.
Explore a child’s claim
Last stop