Indiana · The cap and the Fund
Indiana’s cap on malpractice damages and the Patient’s Compensation Fund
Indiana limits what a malpractice claim under its Act can recover, and splits who pays. A qualified provider pays the first part, and the patient’s compensation fund (opens in a new tab) pays the rest. This page sets out the limit for each period, who pays what, how a claim reaches the Fund, and what a lawyer may charge.
The short answer
What is the cap on medical malpractice damages in Indiana?
For an act of malpractice after June 30, 2019, the total amount recoverable for an injury or death of a patient (opens in a new tab) may not exceed one million eight hundred thousand dollars. A qualified provider is not liable for an amount in excess of (opens in a new tab) five hundred thousand dollars of that, and the rest shall be paid from the patient’s compensation fund (opens in a new tab). Earlier dates carry lower limits. A provider who has not qualified is not covered by this article (opens in a new tab).
How much can a claim recover?
The statute sets one number for the whole of a claim: the total amount recoverable for an injury or death of a patient (opens in a new tab). The date of the malpractice decides which number applies. The limits, for the acts that fall after July 1999, are these:
- An act after June 30, 2019: one million eight hundred thousand dollars (opens in a new tab) in total, with a qualified provider liable for no more than five hundred thousand.
- An act after June 30, 2017 and before July 1, 2019: one million six hundred fifty thousand dollars (opens in a new tab) in total, with a qualified provider liable for no more than four hundred thousand.
- An act after June 30, 1999 and before July 1, 2017: one million two hundred fifty thousand dollars (opens in a new tab) in total, with a qualified provider liable for no more than two hundred fifty thousand.
Who pays what?
The provider, or its insurer, comes first, up to its limit. Any amount due from a judgment or settlement that is in excess of the total liability of all liable health care providers (opens in a new tab) is paid from the Fund, up to the total. Where a provider is liable only because of what its own employee or agent did, the two together pay the total amount (opens in a new tab) of a single provider’s share, and the balance comes from other liable providers or the Fund.
The Fund was created to be collected and received by the commissioner for exclusive use for the purposes stated in this article (opens in a new tab), and it is held in trust. Proceeds of the annual surcharge levied on all health care providers in Indiana (opens in a new tab) go into it. It defends itself: the Commissioner shall retain the services of counsel (opens in a new tab) when a court has to decide a claim against the Fund.
How does a claim reach the Fund?
By a petition to a court, once the provider or its insurer has agreed to settle its liability on a claim by payment of its policy limits (opens in a new tab) and the claimant is asking for more. The petition goes to the court named in the proposed complaint or, at the claimant’s election (opens in a new tab), to the circuit or superior court of Marion County, and it is served on the Commissioner, the provider and the insurer. Objections are due within twenty days after service of summons (opens in a new tab).
The hearing is about the amount. If the parties cannot agree, the court decides the claimant’s damages and what the Fund owes, and it shall consider the liability of the health care provider as admitted and established (opens in a new tab). That means the question left for the court is how much harm the malpractice did.
One line in that statute deserves care. A release executed between the parties does not bar access to the patient’s compensation fund unless the release specifically provides otherwise (opens in a new tab). Have a lawyer read any release before you sign it.
How is the money paid?
The Fund’s share can be paid in one lump amount (opens in a new tab), by periodic payments from the fund over a period of years (opens in a new tab), by the purchase of an annuity payable to the patient (opens in a new tab), or by a combination of them. Claims must be computed and paid not later than sixty days after the issuance of a court approved settlement or final nonappealable judgment (opens in a new tab). If a provider or its insurer does not pay within ninety days, the agreed settlement or final judgment shall be paid from the patient’s compensation fund (opens in a new tab).
What can a lawyer charge?
Indiana limits it. On a claim subject to the panel requirement, the plaintiff’s attorney’s fees may not exceed (opens in a new tab), for an act of malpractice after June 30, 2017, thirty-two percent of any recovery under the cap. A patient also has the right to elect to pay for the attorney’s services on a mutually satisfactory per diem basis (opens in a new tab), and that choice must be exercised in written form at the time of employment (opens in a new tab).
What if the provider is not qualified?
Then none of this applies to that provider. A provider who fails to qualify is not covered by this article and is subject to liability under the law without regard to this article (opens in a new tab), and the patient’s remedy is not affected by this article (opens in a new tab). The page on qualified providers sets out how to find out.
Frequently asked questions
Does the cap apply to every medical malpractice claim in Indiana?
It applies to a claim under the Act. A provider who has not qualified is not covered by this article (opens in a new tab), so that provider’s liability is decided without it.
Which cap applies to my case?
The one for the date of the malpractice, not the date of the claim: the current limit is for an act of malpractice that occurs after June 30, 2019 (opens in a new tab). Care that ran across two periods is a question for a lawyer.
Can I settle with the doctor and still go to the Fund?
Yes, if the settlement is for the provider’s limit and the release leaves the Fund open: a release executed between the parties does not bar access to the patient’s compensation fund unless the release specifically provides otherwise (opens in a new tab).
Does a lawyer’s fee limit apply to the whole recovery?
For an act of malpractice after June 30, 2017, the limit is thirty-two percent of any recovery (opens in a new tab) under the cap. Ask how the fee and the case costs are worked out, and get it in writing.
Keep reading
- 01
Indiana law
The two-year clock, the panel, who the Act covers, your records, a patient’s own fault, the cap, fees and death cases.
Indiana law page - 02
The medical review panel
The proposed complaint, who sits on the panel, what it reads, what it can decide, and what its opinion does.
Explore the medical review panel - 03
Qualified providers
What qualifying means, how to check a provider and the dates of the care, and what changes if the provider is not covered.
Explore qualified providers - 04
A child’s claim
Only a child under six gets more time, to the eighth birthday. Who brings the claim, and how a court reviews a settlement.
Explore a child’s claim
Last stop